Hornsby & Hornsby, Attorneys at Law            (205) 856-1000

Experienced Counsel, a Personal Touch

Slam the Gavel Blog

Do You Really Have a Right to Remain Silent?

Posted by Matthew J. Hornsby on April 18, 2013 at 6:50 PM

          Anyone who has watched an episode of Law & Order, NYPD Blue, or Miami Vice has heard those famous words: “You have the right to remain silent; anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law....” As you may know, it’s known as “Mirandizing” a suspect, a term coined from the Supreme Court case that ruled that police are required to make these and other disclosures prior to “custodial interrogation.”


          Most attorneys, if given the chance, would advise their client to do just that – remain silent. Little good can come from running your mouth in a situation where the police have already decided that you’re their man (or woman, just to be fair). You’re probably not going to talk your way out of the mess, at least not right then. So both practically and legally speaking, the prudent thing to do is to remain silent.


          But what if your silence could be used against you to demonstrate your guilt to the jury later on? In a case before the Supreme Court, prosecutors in Texas had successfully used a defendant’s silence to help prove him guilty of murder to a jury. The trial court judge had allowed the prosecution to argue that by remaining silent in response to questions by police, the defendant basically admitted his guilt. This particular defendant had been freely talking to police until the officer asked him if certain shell casings were going to match a rifle that he had. It seems that the defendant then realized the possibility of a ballistics match for the first time and also realized he may be in trouble after all. So he did exactly what he thought he had the right to do – remain silent. Importantly, he had not yet been arrested, and therefore had not been advised of his rights (Mirandized), nor were the police obligated to Mirandize him at that point.


          But the issue in front of the Supreme Court is whether or not that right to remain silent extends to the time prior to the arrest. Some of the comments of the individual Justices indicate that there is a possibility that the Court may determine that your pre-arrest silence can be used against you to prove guilt. Is it good policy (or even Constitutional) for the police to be able to question you prior to arrest, and then be allowed to use either your answers or your silence against you in court? It seems that such a ruling by the Court would place future suspects in a Catch-22. Either talk to the police and risk incriminating yourself, or don’t talk to police…and risk incriminating yourself.

Categories: None

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In


Reply GeorgeOl
9:14 AM on October 5, 2022 
emprunt de 1000 euros http://www.creditsenligne.org/credit-30000-euros pret de 40000 euros
Reply Williamml
4:00 AM on October 6, 2022 
antabuse generic cheap antabuse 500 mg antabuse cost
Reply Tertsade
6:05 AM on October 6, 2022 
buy generic levitra online levitra cheap levitra
Reply CassiusOl
10:10 AM on October 6, 2022 
besoin de 45000 euros
Reply EbiPAYMN
2:22 PM on October 6, 2022 
atenolol cause gas atenolol how to stop grapefruit juice and atenolol
Reply lisinoprila bep
3:08 PM on October 6, 2022 
lasix 40 mg without a prescription lasix without a prescription lasix 40mg without prescription
Reply Sedinets
11:00 PM on October 6, 2022 
what does ivomec treat in humans where to buy cheap stromectol australia without prescription ivermectin stromectol human
Reply WbzwThede
12:40 AM on October 7, 2022 
what is furosemide side effects lasix buy oral furosemide to torsemide conversion
Reply EmmanuelOl
2:40 PM on October 7, 2022 
emprunt de 1000 euros
Reply Kaydengot
8:36 PM on October 7, 2022 
Autohaus Albertsmeyer GmbH & Co. KG
Reply sinemeto bep
12:37 AM on October 8, 2022 
order lasix 100mg lasix without prescription lasix pills
Reply Propecia bep
3:40 PM on October 8, 2022 
lamisil otc how to buy lamisil lamisil pills
Reply rhirlLab
9:08 PM on October 8, 2022 
priligy delaware where to buy generic priligy cheap online can you mix viagra and priligy
Reply Carsongot
10:59 PM on October 8, 2022 
Opel Rent - Die Autovermietung
Reply JeremiahBype
10:02 AM on October 9, 2022 
15000 Euro Kredit
Reply Torieher
3:18 PM on October 9, 2022 
buffalo thunder resort casino chickasaw nation casinos gold strike casino
Reply Escitalopram bep
6:08 PM on October 9, 2022 
biaxin usa biaxin 250mg australia biaxin generic
Reply canadian pharmacy no prescription required
12:36 AM on October 10, 2022 
best canadian pharmacies
online pharmacy store
Reply Metoclopramide bep
8:28 AM on October 10, 2022 
avapro price avapro 300 mg usa where can i buy avapro